Which Phyllis did you like? Michelle Stafford or Gina Tagnoni?

I Loved Gina when she was on The Guiding Light (I think it was that soap).

Michelle aces Phyllis, always has.

Gina was best imo

Michelle Stafford, she was alwyas my fave actress.

Michelle Stafford by a long shot.  I have been a long time viewer, and so I knew what Phyllis should act like and not act like, and I used to gag when Gina Tagnoni tried to play the part of Phyllis.  You could not even begin to compare the two actresses.  I know we all have our favorites and some may miss Gina, but as for me, I love the acting of Michelle Stafford.

Even though Gina Tognini did a good job of playing Phyllis, Michelle Stafford is better at it.

Michelle Stafford. Gina did an excellent job, it's just that Michelle had been in that role forever. I do miss the hot sex scenes between Nick and Phyllis now that the Covid has ruined it.